which is better iclix or s10?

[emiliecorinne]

So I'm looking to buy a new mp3 player. Someone broke into my car and stole my hidden PMP140. I'm about to move to NYC and can't afford to spend a ton of money to get a large capacity mp3 player, but I need some music!

I've been looking at getting the S10 because it looks so small and convenient. eventually, I'd get something larger and have both. I'm hoping one day, they'll make the clix with at least 40gigs.

So for my purposes of having something small, spending the least amount of money possible- s10 or clix? and does that watch band for the s10 even exist anywhere?

[jko]

I very much like my s10 for the convenience of having a tiny player to hang round my neck and 2G is sufficient for my storage needs (I just chop and change music as I want to). I tend to just stick a bit of a random selection on music on and shuffle it.
But... if you need more space, want to watch movie clips or play games, then the clix is for you.
To be honest, the one that suits your needs is the best player (and that might not even be an iRiver - especially if you want so save on the cost).

Originally Posted by emiliecorinne

and does that watch band for the s10 even exist anywhere?

Consider the practicalities of running the earphone cable up your arm - in your sleeve or outside, what happens when you put a jacket on, how likely is it to snag on something, will it tug out the earphones every time you move your arm?
It might look cool but, imho, it's just a gimmick.

[Step666]

You'd be best reading this thread.

Originally Posted by emiliecorinne

and does that watch band for the s10 even exist anywhere?

No. Well, not least anyway.
It wasn't actually an accessory for the S10, it was a new version of the player with bluetooth. Very little has been heard of it since CES (IIRC) when it was on show but merely as a concept, not as a planned production model. However, last anyone knew, iRiver are still seemingly showing it off so it could still see the light of day.